News and Resources

Sauron’s Eye: OIG Focus on Behavioral Health Providers in 2026

Feb 6, 2026 | News

Every year when the new OIG Worklist comes out, I am reminded of “Sauron’s Eye’ in the Lord of the Rings movies. That eye, menacing and huge, would turn toward whatever captured its focus, the music would swell, and there was almost always some act of warfare that followed. While I am definitely not calling the OIG Worklist an act of war, it can be equally as terrifying when the focus becomes something we do on a daily basis, and think we are doing right.

My eye was caught by the 2026 focus on behavioral health providers, and documentation of psychiatric diagnostic evaluations, psychotherapy alone, and psychotherapy with an evaluation and management (E/M) service – which is where I’d like to mainly focus in this article.

We know that psychotherapy codes are time-based codes – meaning that the length of the visit determines the CPT level of service that is billed. We also know that E/M services can be billed using time or medical decision making. However, when we add an E/M visit along with our psychotherapy service, we can only use medical decision making as our guide to the correct E/M CPT code. In the psychotherapy section of CPT, we are told “time spent on activities of the E/M service is not included in the time used for reporting the psychotherapy service. Time may not be used as the basis of E/M code selection and prolonged services may not be reported when psychotherapy with E/M are reported”. When auditing for these services, we tend to see a blanket “time in/time out” recorded at the beginning of the visit, and often providers forget to carve out and specifically document their time spent only on the psychotherapy portion of the visit, where time is the only deciding factor for the CPT level.

For documentation purposes on these combined visits, the E/M portion of the visit must be significant and separately identifiable. Per CPT, “Medical symptoms and disorders inform treatment choices of psychotherapeutic interventions, and data from therapeutic communication are used to evaluate the presence, type, and severity of medical symptoms and disorders.” We often see combined visits where the documentation of both the E/M and the psychotherapy service are combined and it is difficult to discern the significance of either service, let alone separate the two. In LCD L31887, CMS has provided a Fact Sheet for Outpatient Psychiatry and Psychology Services. In this document, they have outlined the exact documentation required to support a psychotherapy visit – “1) time element is noted, 2) modalities and frequency, 3) clinical notes for each encounter that summarizes the diagnosis, symptoms, functional status, focused mental status exam, treatment plan, prognosis and progress, and 4) name, signature and credentials of the provider”. These services are “face-to-face” services only, and while the visit may include family members or other designated caregivers, the patient must be present for all or some of the time.

So what does documentation for psychotherapy with E/M services look like on the daily? The following information for the specific visit should look something like this:

  • Date of Service
  • Type of Service (is this individual or group?)
  • Time – total time of the visit is fine, but be sure and specifically carve out and document the EXACT amount of time spent on the psychotherapy portion alone (do not use statements such as “I spent at least 16 minutes” or “I spent 16+ minutes” – these times must be specific as time-based coding requires it)
  • Presenting problem and the impact of the problem
  • The mental status and risk of the patient
  • Interventions/therapies used (CBT, DBT, supportive, etc.)
  • The patient’s response to treatment and goals
  • The plan for moving forward
  • Providers’ signature/authorization

Remember that the E/M portion must be separately identifiable, so when monitoring medications, ordering labs, etc., be sure that all the documentation is specific to the reasons the patient is being seen and treated. LCD L31887 also includes documentation requirements for psychiatric diagnostic exams without (CPT 90791) and with medical services (CPT 90792). For both these services, the common requirements are:

  • Elicitation of a complete medical and psychiatric history (including past, family and social)
  • Mental status exam
  • Establishment of an initial diagnosis
  • Evaluation of the patient’s ability and capacity to respond to treatment
  • Initial treatment plan
  • Reported once per day and NOT on the same day as an E/M service performed by the same individual for the same patient
  • Covered once at the outset of an illness or suspected illness

The difference between the documentation requirements and what constitutes “with medical services” is the requirement “Evaluation of the patient’s ability and capacity to respond to treatment”. We often see documentation fall short here.

In an audit situation, common denials are often medical necessity (documentation fails to support the service billed), time is not documented appropriately, signatures are missing, the notes are vague and nondescriptive and finally copy/paste issues. Each of these denials causes delays in payment and can trigger larger audits from payers if documentation is consistently submitted without the requirements. The biggest missing pieces we see during an audit are discussions regarding the treatment plan, the patient’s adherence and progress toward the goals outlined in the treatment plan, and the types of therapies used during that visit. There are many payers who publish their own documentation guidelines for these services, most of which are very resemblant to the CMS guidelines, and we at Granite GRC encourage you to always know your payer guidelines in this field.

Audits are inevitable. Sauron’s eye will turn in your direction; it is just a matter of time. But you can be ready to face any audit situation by following the guidelines above. Know your individual payer guidelines. Work with your providers and your coding teams to understand the documentation requirements and achieve them. Conduct internal pre-bill audits to identify issues prior to claim submission and develop training for those providers whose documentation falls short. Conduct an outside audit, at least once per year, to set fresh eyes on the documentation, as well as satisfy risk assessment portions of your compliance plan. Find a trusted source who can help in any or all these areas – Granite GRC can help! Be sure your practice is ready when the eye falls on you.

Resources

  • https://www.cgsmedicare.com/partb/medicalpolicy/index.html
  • https://www.cms.gov/medicare-coverage-database/view/lcd.aspx?LCDId=34353&DocID=L34353
  • https://www.cms.gov/medicare-coverage-
  • https://www.cms.gov/medicare-coverage-database/view/article.aspx?articleId=57065&LCDId=34353&ContrId=228&ContrVer=2&CntrctrSelected=228*2&Cntrctr=228&DocType=2

Need a second set of eyes before the OIG’s turn your way?

Granite GRC works with behavioral health organizations to strengthen documentation, coding accuracy, and audit readiness. Crystal Stalter, Director of Revenue Cycle Assessment and Compliance, partners directly with providers and compliance teams to identify gaps, improve defensibility, and align documentation with payer and CMS expectations. If you want added confidence that your records will stand up to scrutiny, reach out to Crystal at (717) 556-1090 or at crs@granitegrcconsulting.com